[TxRateFilingPulse](/v/txratefilingpulse) / compare

# Consumers County Mutual Insurance Company vs Navigators Insurance Company: TxRateFilingPulse comparison

**Consumers County Mutual Insurance Company's rate change (%) of 20 is 1.0x Navigators Insurance Company's 20 (82nd percentile). Consumers County Mutual Insurance Company is dated 2026-10-06; Navigators Insurance Company 2026-07-29.**

Data as of 2026-11-05 · [Compiled by Zalwin](/research/txratefilingpulse) from Texas Department of Insurance property and casualty rate filings (data.texas.gov) Copy citation

Download the newest 500 TxRateFilingPulse records (CSV) — $4.99 →

Both records plus every comparable record, with all columns and source links · Card, Apple Pay, Google Pay or Link via Stripe

## How does Consumers County Mutual Insurance Company compare to Navigators Insurance Company?

| Field | Consumers County Mutual Insurance Company | Navigators Insurance Company |
|---|---|---|
| Insurer | Consumers County Mutual Insurance Company | Navigators Insurance Company |
| Line | Commercial Automobile / Business Auto | Commercial Automobile / Business Auto |
| Product | Transportation Program | Navigators Commercial Auto NCP |
| Overall rate change | +19.9% | +19.8% |
| Received by TDI | 2026-10-06 | 2026-07-29 |
| Effective for new business | 2027-01-01 | 2026-11-16 |
| Effective for renewals | 2027-01-01 | 2026-11-16 |
| Status | Pending review | Reviewed and closed |
| SERFF tracking number | CCMC-135115973 | NAVG-135016774 |
| rate change (%) percentile | 82nd | 82nd |
| Score | 85/100 | 70/100 |
| Peer rank and all 500 records (CSV) | Every comparable record ranked, with amounts, dates and scores 🔒 Click to unlock → |
| Official source URLs for every peer record | Direct links to each record at its government source 🔒 Click to unlock → |

Official records: [Consumers County Mutual Insurance Company](https://data.texas.gov/d/ittv-5xew) · [Navigators Insurance Company](https://data.texas.gov/d/ittv-5xew)

## Get new Texas rate filings

TxRateFilingPulse emails new TDI filings matching your lines, statuses and rate-change threshold.

Download all matching records (CSV) — $4.99 → [See plans](/v/txratefilingpulse#pricing)

From the Texas Department of Insurance rate filing data, as posted. The overall rate change is the filer's statewide figure and individual policies can move more or less; many filings change rules or forms with no rate change. Filings may be amended after review. Check the SERFF filing before relying on it.

## Often used together

- [TruckInsuranceCancelPulse](/v/truckinsurancecancelpulse)
- [TxNonsubscriberPulse](/v/txnonsubscriberpulse)
- [WarnLayoffPulse](/v/warnlayoffpulse)
- [SitemapHealthPulse](/sitemaphealthpulse)
- [PrivateOfferingMarketingAudit](/privateofferingmarketingaudit)
- [SecurityIntegratorNdaaAudit](/securityintegratorndaaaudit)